Question 340General Subjects - 1st Asst/Chief

70% to pass

Once a fire and emergency drill is conducted, the drill ideally should be critiqued. What of the following statements best describes the essential characteristics of an effective critique?

ADetermining what went right and what went wrong and identifying areas where change and improvements are necessary to the fire control plan or to the general arrangement plan.
BDetermining what went right and what went wrong and identifying areas where change and improvements are necessary to the pre-fire plan or to the emergency skills training plan.
CDetermining what went right only and focusing only on the positive to reinforce effective and productive behavior that promoted team functionality.
DDetermining what went wrong only and focusing only on the negative in an attempt to extinguish ineffective or counter-productive behavior that worked against team functionality.
AI Explanation

The correct answer is B) Determining what went right and what went wrong and identifying areas where change and improvements are necessary to the pre-fire plan or to the emergency skills training plan. This is the best answer because an effective critique of a fire and emergency drill should focus on both the positive and negative aspects of the drill. The goal is to identify what worked well, so those effective practices can be reinforced, and also identify areas that need improvement, such as the pre-fire plan or emergency skills training, so changes and updates can be made. This balanced approach allows for continuous improvement of emergency preparedness. The other options are less effective. Option A focuses too narrowly on just the fire control plan and general arrangement plan. Option C focuses only on the positive, which misses opportunities for improvement. Option D focuses only on the negative, which can be demoralizing and fail to reinforce effective practices.

Want to practice with timed exams?

Download Coast Guard Exams for the full exam experience.

Get the App